The Sisters Behind the Operation

Family Focused. Community Minded.

Request a Wedding Cake Consultation Today!

Call 708.614.9755

Meet Becky Palermo & Beth Fahey


Becky Palermo
Becky Palermo

Becky Palermo’s refined, elegant style has made her one of the most sought after cake decorators in the Chicagoland area. A cake decorator for over 25 years, Becky has designed thousands of wedding cakes, and countless special occasion cakes. Cake decorating is an art form that calls for skill and precision, and Becky never fails to deliver anything but the best.

Beth Fahey

Beth Fahey is the yin to Becky’s yang. She can ice a mean cake and is in charge of all things business and marketing at Creative Cakes. Beth serves on the Board of Directors for the Chicago Area Retail Bakers Association and is the new president of the Retail Bakers of America. She is also a member of Vistage and serves on Tinley Park’s Main Street Commission.

Beth Fahey

CC Rewards Special of the Day

Saturday: 25% OFF Chocolate Sundae Cupcakes

Deals are only for Creative Cakes Rewards Members making walk-in purchases. Cannot be combined with other offers or coupons. Some offers are subject to restrictions. Quantities may be limited.

See All July Specials
The story behind our “Peachy-Keen” Pie

Our dad, Rob Cotter, is an amazing man. While he’s been through a lot in...
CC’s Core Values Series: Make the Next Person Successful

If you’ve been to our bakery-café before, you’ve likely noticed our staff members’ T-shirts proclaiming...
Community Oven Days 2016

Well, another year, another Christmas, another round of Community Oven Days! What is Community Oven...
Wedding Cake FAQs

We've been making wedding cakes for over 27 years. Over that time, many people have...
We’ve Got Holiday Gift Baskets, Cookie Tins, and Corporate Logo Cookies!

Cookie Tins and Gift Baskets Small Mini Butter Cookie Tin Small Spritz Cookie Tin Small...

Catering & Delivery Are Available!

Try something new and fresh from our café for your next gathering.


16649 Oak Park Ave
Tinley Park, IL 60477
(In Rubino's Plaza)


Tuesday - Saturday: 8am to 6pm
Sunday: 8am to 4pm
Closed on Monday

© Copyright 2017 Creative Cakes Bakery & Café. | Store Policies
Tinley Park IL Web Design by Idea Marketing Group